June 25, 2026 · Updated October 22, 2026 · Hiring · Metro Vancouver
Handyman vs Contractor in Vancouver: When to Call Which
Handyman vs contractor in BC: where Technical Safety BC, city permits and BC Housing draw the line, and which one your job needs. From an insured local crew.
The handyman vs contractor question comes up on almost every call we get in Metro Vancouver. People are not sure who to hire, so they either overpay a contractor for a half-day job or wait weeks for a callback that never comes. The line between the two is simpler than it looks, and knowing it saves you both.
Not sure which side your job falls on? Send photos and we will tell you straight, even if the honest answer is “that one needs a contractor.”
What is the difference between a handyman and a contractor?
A handyman handles repairs and small projects that take hours to a few days and need no permit: fences, decks, drywall, tile, doors, cabinets. A general contractor runs the big, permitted builds that change the structure and need several licensed trades scheduled and managed together. The line is about permits, structure, and trade count, not about skill. Most of what goes wrong is hiring the wrong one for the job in front of you.
Forget job titles for a second. Three things decide which one you need.
- Permits. If the work needs a building permit, it is contractor territory. Structural changes, additions, anything that alters the building.
- Structure. Moving a load-bearing wall is a contractor job. Patching the drywall on it is ours.
- How many trades. One or two skill sets, a handyman crew covers it. A job that needs framing, electrical, plumbing, and tile all scheduled in sequence needs someone managing the whole thing.
If your job clears all three, no permit, no structural change, one or two trades, you almost certainly want a handyman. Hiring a general contractor for it means paying for project management you do not need.
Which jobs go to a handyman and which to a contractor?
Repairs that take hours or days and need no building permit go to a handyman: rotten fence posts, a vanity swap, soft deck boards, drywall after a leak. Removing a wall, building a suite with new plumbing and wiring, or an addition goes to a general contractor. Most home jobs sit between the two, and those are the ones worth a phone call before you decide.
Handyman calls: a fence with three rotten posts and a leaning panel. A bathroom vanity and sink swap. A cedar deck with soft boards that need replacing and sealing. Drywall and a cabinet rebuilt after a slow under-sink leak. Garage door spring gone. Tile backsplash. These are hours-to-days jobs, no permit, and they make up most of the work we do.
Contractor calls: taking the wall out between a kitchen and living room. A basement suite with new plumbing and electrical and a permit. A full addition. We will tell you when a job is one of these, and sometimes we will point you to the right kind of trade for it.
The in-between, which is most of it: a multi-day, multi-trade refresh that still does not need a permit. A kitchen that needs cabinet work, tile, a counter, and paint, but no walls moved. That middle ground is where an owner-led crew fits best. Big enough to handle the whole list, small enough that the same people see it through.
Why won’t a contractor call back about a small job?
A general contractor booked on a renovation will not break it up to come hang your doors. So one of two things happens: they quote high enough to make the interruption worth it, or they take your number and you never hear back. It is not personal. The math does not work for them, and a job that is too big to ignore but too small for a contractor is the work a handyman crew is built for.
We answer the phone for it.
What does BC law say a handyman can’t do?
BC has no handyman licence, so the limits come from the regulated trades. Electrical and gas work falls under Technical Safety BC and has to be done by a licensed contractor, and replacing a light fixture or a ceiling fan already counts. In Vancouver, installing, changing or upgrading plumbing needs a city plumbing permit. New homes must be built by a Licensed Residential Builder registered with BC Housing.
Here is where each line sits, with the official source for each one.
- Electrical. Technical Safety BC requires a permit to replace light fixtures or ceiling fans, move switches or outlets, or hard-wire equipment like a dishwasher or range hood. A licensed contractor takes the permit out for you. A homeowner doing their own work may qualify for a homeowner permit, but strata owners cannot get one. In Vancouver, Burnaby, Surrey, North Vancouver, West Vancouver and Maple Ridge, the city issues electrical permits instead of Technical Safety BC.
- Gas. Gas work also runs on Technical Safety BC licences and permits. Since December 1, 2023, gasfitter has been one of BC’s compulsory trades, along with construction electrician, so the person doing the work must be certified or a registered apprentice.
- Plumbing. The City of Vancouver needs a permit to install, change or upgrade any part of a plumbing system, and only a licensed plumbing contractor can apply, unless you are working on a single-family house you own and live in. Repairing a leak, clearing a drain, or replacing a faucet or fixture in the same spot needs no permit. Other cities set their own rules.
- Fire separations. Vancouver’s permit list includes drywall repairs to fire separations in multi-unit residential buildings. In a strata building, ask the property manager whether a corridor or suite wall is a rated separation before anyone patches it.
- New homes and building envelopes. Under the Homeowner Protection Act, a new home has to be built by a Licensed Residential Builder and covered by 2-5-10 home warranty insurance. A building envelope renovation needs a licensed building envelope renovator. Repairs and maintenance need neither.
When a job crosses one of these lines, we tell you up front and bring in the proper trade for that part. We handle the carpentry, drywall, tile, trim and paint around it, so you are not left with work that fails an inspection or an insurance claim. We would rather lose that line item than do work that should have a permit behind it.
So which one do you call?
Run your job through three questions: does it need a building permit, does it change the structure, and does it need more than a couple of trades coordinated? Three nos, call a handyman. Several yeses, call a general contractor. Somewhere in the middle, which is where most home jobs live, call us and we will give you a real answer.
Once you have picked, our guide to hiring a handyman without getting burned walks through what to check before you book.
Call (604) 996-0969 or book a free estimate. If your job needs a contractor, we will say so. That honesty is most of why people call us back.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a handyman and a contractor in BC?
A handyman handles repairs and small projects that take hours to a few days and do not need a permit. A general contractor manages larger builds: structural work, permits, and several licensed trades scheduled together. The line is mostly about permits, structure, and how many trades have to be coordinated, not about how skilled the person is.
Do I need a permit for handyman work in Metro Vancouver?
Most small repairs do not. In Vancouver, replacing cabinets or flooring, painting, and non-structural exterior repairs need no building permit, while moving walls or plumbing, electrical or gas lines, structural repairs, and building or altering a deck do. Electrical work is permitted separately, even a light fixture swap. Each municipality sets its own rules, so Burnaby and Surrey can differ.
Why won't a contractor call me back about a small job?
Small jobs are not worth a general contractor's time when they are booked on bigger builds. So they quote high to make it worthwhile, or they never call back. That gap, the job too big to ignore but too small for a contractor, is exactly the work a handyman crew is built for.
Can a handyman do electrical or plumbing work in BC?
Not the regulated parts. Electrical work, including replacing a light fixture or ceiling fan, has to be done by a contractor licensed with Technical Safety BC, and gas work by a licensed gas contractor. In Vancouver, new or changed plumbing needs a permit that only a licensed plumbing contractor can take out, though replacing a faucet or fixture in the same spot does not. A handyman handles the carpentry, drywall and tile around that work.